Microleakage of Sealants after Phosphoric Acid, Er: YAG Laser and Air Abrasion Enamel Conditioning: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Purpose: The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to answer the focused question: Does the application of phosphoric acid, Er:YAG laser and air abrasion enamel conditioning methods previous to the oclusal sealant application in human permanent molars influence the microleakage? Study design: A literature research was carried out in the Pubmed Medline, Web of Science, Scopus and Cochrane databases using with the MeSH terms and keyword search strategy. A supplemental hand search of the references of retrieved articles was also performed. Inclusion criteria comprised ex vivo studies (extracted teeth) with permanent human teeth that used chemical (phosphoric acid) or mechanical (Er:YAG laser and air abrasion) conditioning methods previous the sealant application. The studies should evaluate microleakage as an outcome. Meta-analysis pooled plot were obtained comparing the microleakage after pre-treatment with phosphoric acid, Er:YAG and air abrasion enamel conditioning for sealant application using RevMan software. Results: The search resulted in 164 articles, 55 records were excluded because they were duplicated. The analysis of titles and abstracts resulted in the exclusion of 105 studies. Four studies were included in the systematic review and the meta-analysis. According to the risk of bias evaluation, the four studies were considered low risk of bias. The meta-analysis showed that phosphoric acid had lower microleakage than Er:YAG laser (p < 0.001) and air abrasion (p < 0.001), with heterogeinity of I² = 0% and I² = 71%, respectively. It was not found statistical difference when compared phosphoric acid and phosphoric acid combined with Er:YAG laser and air abrasion (p > 0.05). Conclusion: The evidence supports that the pretreatment with phosphoric acid leads lower microleakage in oclusal sealants than Er:YAG laser and air abrasion.

Microleakage; Sealants; Enamel conditioning; Systematic review; Meta-analysis

1. Gooch BF, Griffin SO, Gray SK, Kohn WG, Rozier RG, Siegal M, et al., Preventing dental caries through school-based sealant programs: updated recommendations and reviews of evidence. J Am Dent Assoc; 140:1356– 1365. 2009.

2. Braga MM, Martignon S, Ekstrand KR, Ricketts DN, Imparato JC, Mendes FM. Parameters associated with active caries lesions assessed by two different visual scoring systems on occlusal surfaces of primary molars—a multilevel approach. Comm Dent Oral Epidemiol; 38:549–558. 2010.

3. Hormati AA, Fuller JL, Denehy GE. Effects of contamination and mechanical disturbance on the quality of acid-etched enamel. J Am Dent Assoc; 100:34–38. 1980.

4. Bader C, Krejci I. Indications and limitations of Er:YAG laser applications in dentistry. Am J Dent; 19:178–186. 2006.

5. Borsatto MC, Giuntini Jde L, Contente MM, Gomes-Silva JM, Torres CP, Galo R. Self-etch bonding agent beneath sealant: Bond strength for laser -irradiated enamel. Eur J Dent; 7:289-95. 2013.

6. Hatibovic-Kofman S, Wright GZ, Braverman I. Microleakage of sealants after conventional, bur, and air-abrasion preparation of pits and fissures. Ped Dent; 20:173–176. 1998.

7. Wright GZ, Hatibovic-Kofman S, Millenaar DW, Braverman, I. The safety and efficacy of treatment with air abrasion technology. Int J Ped Dent; 9:133–140. 1999.

8. Borsatto MC, Corona SAM, Palma-Dibb RG, Pécora JD. Microleakage of a resin sealant after acid-etching, Er:YAG Laser irradiation and air abrasion of pits and fissures. J Clin Laser Med Surg; 19: 83-87. 2001.

9. Borsatto MC, Corona SA, Ramos RP, Liporaci JL, Pécora JD, Palma–Dibb RG. Microleakage at sealant/enamel interface of primary teeth: effect of Er:YAG laser ablation of pits and fissures. J Dent Child; 71: 143–147. 2004.

10. Chimello–Sousa DT, de Souza AE, Chinelatti MA, Pécora JD, Palma–Dibb RG, Milori Corona SA. Influence of Er:YAG laser irradiation distance on the bond strength of a restorative system to enamel. J Dent; 34:245–251. 2006.

11. Wanderley RL, Monghini EM, Pecora JD, Palma–Dibb RG, Borsatto, MC. Shear bond strength to the enamel of primary teeth irradiated with varying Er:YAG laser energies and SEM examination of the surface morphology: an in vitro study. Photom Surg; 23:260– 267. 2005.

12. Christensen GJ. Air abrasion tooth cutting: state of the art 1998. The Journal of the Am Dent Assoc; 129:484–485. 1998.

13. Neuhaus KW, Ciucchi P, Donnet M, Lussi A. Removal of enamel caries with an air abrasion powder. Op Dent; 35:538–546. 2010.

14. Moher D, Shamseer L, Clarke M, Ghersi D, Liberati A, Petticrew M, Shekelle P, Stewart LA. PRISMA-P Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) statement. Syst Rev 2015; 4:1. 2015.

15. Maia LC and Antonio AG. Systematic reviews in dental research. A guideline. The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry (Print); 37:117-124. 2012.

16. Lenzi TL, Gimenez T, Tedesco TK, Mendes FM, Rocha RO, Raggio DP. Adhesive systems for restoring primary teeth: a systematic review and meta-analysis of in vitro studies. Int J Paediatr Dent; 12:1-12. 2015.

17. Sarkis-Onofre R, Skupien JA, Cenci MS, Moraes RR, Pereira-Cenci T. The role of resin cement on bond strength of glass-fiber posts luted into root canals: a systematic review and meta-analysis of in vitro studies. Oper Dent; 39:31-44. 2014.

18. Hozo SP, Djulbegovic B, Hozo I. Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample. BMC Med Res Method; 5:13. 2005.

19. Ciucchi P, Neuhaus K, Emerich M, Peutzfeldt A, Lussi A. Evaluation of different types of enamel conditioning before application of a fissure sealant. Lasers Med Sci; 30:1-9. 2015.

20. Manhart J, Huth KC, Chen, HY, Hickel, R. Influence of the pretreatment of occlusal pits and fissures on the retention of a fissure sealant. Am J Dent; 17:12-18. 2004.

21. Sancakli HS, Erdemir U, Yildiz E. Effects of Er:YAG Laser anda ir abrasion on the Microleakage of a resin-based fissure sealant material. Photomed Laser Surg; 29, 485-492. 2011.

22. Eduardo CP, Myaki SI, Oliveira Jr WT, Aranachavez VE, Tanji E. Micromorphological evaluation of enamel surface and the shear bond strength of a composite resin after Er:YAG laser irradiation: An in vitro study. 5th Congress of International Society for Laser in Dentistry. Jerusalem, Israel, 5–9. 1996.

23. Laurell, KA., and Hess, JA. Scanning electron micrographic effects of air-abrasion cavity preparation on human enamel and dentin. Quintess Int; 26: 139–144. 1995.

24. Boston DW, Alperstein KS, Boberick K. Cavosurface margin geometry in conventional and air abrasion class V cavity preparations. Am J Dent;10:97- 101. 1997.

25. Guirguis R, Lee J, Conry J. Microleakage of restorations prepared with air abrasion. J Ped Dent; 21:311–315. 1999.

26. Olsen ME, Bishara SE, Damon P, Jakobsen JR. Comparison of shear bond strength and surface structure between conventioal acid etching and air-abrasion of human enamel. Am J Orthod Dent Orthop; 112: 502–506. 1997.

27. Kitchens DH. The economics of pit and fissure sealants in preventive dentistry: a review. J Contemp Dent Pract; 6:95–103. 2005.

28. A Comparative Clinical Study of Three Fissure Sealants on Primary Teeth: 24-Month Results. Ünal M, Oznurhan F, Kapdan A, Dürer S. J Clin Ped Dent; 39:113-119. 2015.