Bioethical Issues in Conducting Pediatric Dentistry Clinical Research

Pediatric clinical research on new drugs and biomaterials involves children in order to create valid and generalizable knowledge. Research on vulnerable populations, such as children, is necessary but only admissible when researchers strictly follow methodological and ethical standards, together with the respect to human rights; and very especially when the investigation cannot be conducted with other population or when the potential benefits are specifically for that age group. Clinical research in Pediatric Dentistry is not an exception. The aim of the present article was to provide the bioethical principles (with respect to the child/parents' autonomy, benefit/risk analysis, and distributive justice), and recommendations, including informed consent, research ethics committees, conflict of interest, and the “equipoise” concept. Current and future worldwide oral health research in children and adolescents must be conducted incorporating their perspectives in the decision-making process as completely as possible. This concept must be carefully considered when a dental clinical study research is going to be planned and conducted, especially in the case of randomized controlled trials, in which children will be recruited as participants.

Bioethical, Child, Clinical Research, Randomized Controlled Trial

1. Gibbons DE. Medical and dental research. In: Lambden P, ed. Dental law and ethics. Oxon, UK: Radcliffe Medical Press; 2002.

2. Roth-Cline M, Gerson J, Bright P, Lee CS, Nelson RM. Ethical consid-erations in conducting pediatric research. Handb Exp Pharmacol; 205: 219–244, 2011.

3. Marshman Z, Innes N, Deery C, et al. The management of dental caries in primary teeth–involving service providers and users in the design of a trial. Trials; 13: 143, 2012.

4. Ellen RP, Singleton R. Human rights and ethical considerations in oral health research. J Can Dent Assoc; 74: 439a–439e, 2008.

5. Innes NPT, Clarkson JE, Speed C, Douglas GVA, Maguire A, FiCTION Trial Collaboration. The FiCTION dental trial protocol – filling children’s teeth: Indicated or not? BMC Oral Health;13: 25, 2013.

6. International Ethical Guideline for Health-related Research Involving Humans. 4th. Ed. Geneva, Switzerland. Council for International Organi-zations of Medical Sciences (CIOMS); 2106.

7. Marshman Z, Hall MJ. Oral health research in children. Int J Paediatr Dent;18: 235–242, 2008.

8. Marshman Z, Gupta E, Baker SR, et al. Seen and heard: Towards child participation in dental research. Int J Paediatr Dent; 25: 375–382, 2015.

9. Wallace A, Rogers HJ, Zaitoun H, Rodd HD, Gilchrist F, Marshman Z. Traumatic dental injury research: On children or with children. Dent Traumatol; 33:153–159, 2017.

10. Marshman Z, Gibson BJ, Owens J, et al. Seen but not heard: A system-atic review of the place of children in 21st-century dental research. Int J Paediatr Dent; 17: 320–327, 2007.

11. Marshman Z. ‘The voice of the child in the oral health research’ (Guest Editorial). Int J Paediatr Dent; 25: 309, 2015.

12. Innes NPT, Schwendicke F, Lamont T. How do we create, and improve, the evidence base? Brit Dent J; 220: 651–655, 2016.

13. Mehnaz-Mirza A. Importance of informed consent in dentistry. Int Dent J Stud Res; 1: 13–16, 2012.

14. Gustafsson BE, Quensel CE, Lanke LS, et al. The Vipeholm dental caries study; the effect of different levels of carbohydrate intake on caries activity in 436 individuals observed for five years. Acta Odontol Scand; 11: 232–264, 1954.

15. van Delden JJM, van der Graaf R. Revised CIOMS International Ethical Guidelines for Health-realted Research Involving Humans. J Am Med Assoc (published on line, December 2016):E1-E2. Doi: 10.1001/jama.2016.18977.

16. Yan EG. Munir KM. Regulatory and ethical principles in research involving children and individuals with developmental disabilities. Ethics Behav; 14: 31–49, 2004.

17. World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki. Ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects. J Am Med Assoc; 310: 2191–2194, 2013.

18. Emanuel EJ, Wendler D, Grady Ch. What makes clinical research ethical? JADA; 283: 2701–2711, 2006.

19. Henschel AD, Rothenberger LG, Boos J. Randomized clinical trials in children–Ethical and methodological issues. Curr Pharm Des; 16: 2407–2415, 2010.

20. Hujoel PP. Levels of clinical significance. J Evid Base Dent Pract; 4: 32–36, 2004.

21. Caldwell PHY, Murphy SB, Butow PN, Craig JC. Clinical trials in chil-dren. Lancet; 364: 803–811, 2004.

22. Moher D, Hopewell S, Schulz KF, et al. CONSORT 2010 explanation and elaboration: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomized trials. BMJ; 340: c869, 2010.

23. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Clinical Trial Regis-tration. Available at: http://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/publishing-and-editorial-issues/clinical-trial-registration.html. Accessed on November 3, 2016.

24. Chalmers I, Bracken MB, Djulbegobic B, et al. How to increase value and reduce waste when research priorities are set. Lancet; 383: 156–165, 2014.

25. Gilchrist F, Rodd HD, Deery C, Marshman Z. Involving children in research, audit and service evaluation. Br Dent J; 214: 577–582, 2013.

26. Katz AL, Webb SA; COMMITTEE ON BIOETHICS. Informed consent in decision-making in pediatric practice. Pediatrics; 138, 2016.

27. The free dictionary (by Farlex). http://medical-dictionary.thefreedictio-nary.com/informed+consent. Accessed on April 11, 2016.

28. American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. Clinical practice guideline: Guideline on informed consent. Pediatr Dent (Reference manual); 37: 95–97, 2015-16.

29. Hein IM, De Vries MC, Troost PW, Meynen G, Van Goudoever JB, Lindauer RJL. Informed consent instead of assent is appropriate in children from the age of twelve: Policy implications of new findings on children’s competence to consent clinical research. BMC Med Ethics; 16: 76–82, 2015.

30. Shaw C, Brady LM, Davey C. Guidelines for research with children and young people. National Children’s Bureau. London, UK; pp. 27–33, 2011.

31. Leventhal N, Tarini B, Lantos J. Ethical issues in neonatal and pediatric clinical trials. Pediatr Clin North Am; 59: 1205–1220, 2012.

32. Foreman DM. The family rule: A framework for obtaining ethical consent for medical interventions from children. J Med Ethics; 25: 491–496, 1999.

33. Roth-Cline M, Nelson R. Parental permission and child assent in research on children. Yale J Biol Med; 86: 291–301, 2013.

34. Cerda-Cristerna BI, Garrocho-Rangel JA, Pozos-Guillén AJ. El consen-timiento informado en la investigación clínica en Estomatología. ADM; 71: 301–305, 2014.

35. Kaushik JS, Narang M, Agarwal N. Informed consent in pediatric prac-tice. Indian Pediatr; 47: 1039–1046, 2010.

36. University of California in Los Angeles (UCLA). Office of the Human Research Protection Program. Guidance and procedures: Child assent and permission by parents or guardians. http://ora.research.ucla.edu/OHRPP/Documents/Policy/9/ChildAssent_ParentPerm.pdf. Last updated: June 9, 2016. Acceded on September 29, 2016.

37. UK Data Archive. Available at: http://www.data-archive.ac.uk/media/112616/ukdaconsentchild.pdf. Acceded on October 15, 2016.

38. Bartolome W. Ethical issues in pediatric research. In: Vanderpoon H, ed. The ethics of research involving human subjects. Fredrerick, MD: University Publishing Group; 1996.

39. UK Health Departments. Research Ethics Service. Standard operating procedures for research ethics committees. Version 7.1, October, 2016. Available at: http://hra.nhs.uk/documents/2016/10/res-standard-operat-ing-procedures-version-7-1.pdf.

40. Rodd H, Hall M, Deery C, Gilchrist F, Gibson BJ, Marshman Z. ‘I felt weird and wobbly’. Child reported impacts associated with a dental general anaesthetic. Br Dent J; 216: E17, 2014.

41. Cerda-Cristerna BI, Garrocho-Rangel JA, Pozos-Guillén AJ. Comité de Ética en Investigación: La consciencia del investigador para la protección del sujeto participante en una investigación clínica en Estomatología. ADM; 71: 256–260, 2014.

42. ICH Practice Guidelines. Available at: http://www.ich.org/products/guidelines.html. Accessed on April 8, 2016.

43. Barnett ML. University-industry relationships in dentistry: Past, present, future. J Dent Educ; 66: 1163–1168, 2002.